ℹ️This page may contain affiliate links. We earn a commission if you purchase through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more
Updated 2026-03-08
Topstep vs SpiceProp: Which Prop Firm Is Better?
Choosing between Topstep and SpiceProp comes down to whether you prioritize established reliability or aggressive profit splits. Topstep offers a unique single-phase evaluation with no daily loss limits and daily payouts, while SpiceProp provides a higher starting profit split at 60% and more flexible minimum trading requirements. This comparison examines their evaluation structures, payout terms, and risk management rules to help you determine which firm aligns with your trading style and experience level.
T
Topstep
Est. 2012 · Chicago, USA
4.4
14,000 reviews
VS
3 wins
5 ties
3 wins
S
SpiceProp
Est. 2023 · N/A
4
200 reviews
Feature
Topstep
SpiceProp
Challenge Price ($100K)
N/A
$479
Phase 1 Profit Target
N/A
10%
Phase 2 Profit Target
None (single-phase)✓ Single-phase evaluation
5%
Max Daily Loss
No limit✓ No daily loss limit
5.5%
Max Total Loss
N/A
11%
Min Trading Days
5 days
3 days✓ More flexible
Time Limit (Phase 1)
No limit
No limit
Payout Split
50% (up to 90%)
60% (up to 90%)✓ Higher starting split
Topstep
Pros
+Performance-based capital release structure with 20% initial access scaling to full balance
+Daily payout eligibility after 30 benchmark trading days with up to 90% profit split
+Performance bonus program offering over $250,000 in cash bonuses for consistent traders
+Dynamic risk expansion that adjusts daily loss limits as account balance grows
+Live Funded Account structure designed to help transition from simulated to live trading
Cons
−Must maintain account balance above $0 at all times or forfeit account
−Initial payout split limited to 50% until reaching 30 benchmark trading days
−Account automatically closed if inactive for 90 days
−All positions must be closed by 3:10 PM CT daily
−Protective stops required on every open position
SpiceProp
Pros
+Multiple account types including no-step Jalapeño program
+All-asset trading including Forex, Indices, Metals, Stocks, Commodities, ETFs
+24/7 customer support and SpiceProp Academy for education
+Unlimited trading period with no time restrictions
+High leverage up to 1:100 across all asset classes
Cons
−Relatively new firm established in 2023 with limited track record
−Some programs have restrictive account limits (Black Pepper only 1 account)
−Lower profit splits starting at 60% for some programs
−Higher daily drawdown limits compared to some competitors
Our Verdict
Which Should You Choose?
Topstep is the better choice for experienced traders who value operational reliability and flexible risk management. The single-phase evaluation eliminates the stress of multi-phase targets, while the absence of daily loss limits gives seasoned traders room to manage drawdowns without arbitrary cutoffs. Daily payouts and 12 years of operational history provide confidence that your earnings will arrive on schedule.
SpiceProp suits newer traders willing to trade higher profit splits for stricter risk controls. The 60% starting split beats Topstep's 50%, and the 3-day minimum trading requirement offers more scheduling flexibility. However, the 5.5% daily loss limit and 5% Phase 2 profit target create additional pressure points that could trip up inconsistent traders.
For most traders, Topstep's proven track record and simplified evaluation structure outweigh SpiceProp's profit split advantage, especially given Topstep's trustpilot score of 4.4/5 from 14,000 reviews versus SpiceProp's 4/5 from just 200 reviews.
Choose Topstep if:
→Performance-based capital release structure with 20% initial access scaling to full balance
→Daily payout eligibility after 30 benchmark trading days with up to 90% profit split
→Performance bonus program offering over $250,000 in cash bonuses for consistent traders
→Dynamic risk expansion that adjusts daily loss limits as account balance grows
Choose SpiceProp if:
→Multiple account types including no-step Jalapeño program
→All-asset trading including Forex, Indices, Metals, Stocks, Commodities, ETFs
→24/7 customer support and SpiceProp Academy for education
→Unlimited trading period with no time restrictions
Disclaimer:This comparison is for informational purposes only. Prop firm rules change regularly — always verify current terms on each firm's official website before purchasing a challenge. This is not financial advice. Updated 2026-03-08.