The5ers vs Blue Guardian: Which Prop Firm Is Better?
Traders choosing between The5ers and Blue Guardian face a fundamental trade-off between proven reliability and platform flexibility. The5ers offers a superior 100% profit split compared to Blue Guardian's 80-90%, while Blue Guardian provides MT4/MT5 access and unrestricted news trading that The5ers doesn't match. With The5ers established since 2016 and Blue Guardian launching in 2022, this comparison examines how their different strengths align with various trading styles and priorities.
T
The5ers
Est. 2016 · Raanana, Israel
4.8
21,000 reviews
VS
1 wins
8 ties
2 wins
BG
Blue Guardian
Est. 2022 · N/A
4.3
1,500 reviews
Feature
The5ers
Blue Guardian
Challenge Price ($100K)
N/A
$506
Phase 1 Profit Target
10%
10%
Max Daily Loss
3%
3%
Max Total Loss
6%
6%
Time Limit (Phase 1)
No limit
No limit
Payout Split
100%✓ Higher profit split
80% (up to 90%)
Payout Frequency
monthly
instant
Platforms
N/A
MT4, MT5✓ More platform options
The5ers
Pros
+Scale up to $4M in funded trading capital with industry-leading spreads
+Up to 100% profit split with transparent one-time fees
+Unlimited time limit for evaluations with no consistency rules
+24/7 support and guidance with free educational resources
+10+ years active with 262K funded traders and reliable payouts
Cons
−Limited leverage at 1:30 compared to some competitors
−One-time fee of $260 applies to all account sizes
−Daily pause rule at 3% may limit aggressive trading strategies
Blue Guardian
Pros
+Instant funding accounts available - skip evaluation phases entirely
+Scale up to $4M in funding capacity
+Instant payouts and 24-hour payout guarantee available
+Multiple account types including 1-step, 2-step, and 3-step challenges
+100% refundable fees after fourth payout
Cons
−Relatively new firm established in 2022
−Lower leverage ratios compared to some competitors (1:30 max for most instruments)
−Limited transparency on company background and headquarters location
−Higher fees for larger account sizes compared to some established competitors
Our Verdict
Which Should You Choose?
The5ers suits traders who prioritize maximum profit retention and proven track record over platform variety. The 100% profit split versus Blue Guardian's 80-90% means significantly more money in your pocket on every withdrawal, while the 4.8/5 Trustpilot rating from 21,000+ reviews demonstrates consistent performance over nearly a decade.
Blue Guardian better serves traders who need MT4/MT5 specifically or rely heavily on news trading strategies. The platform access and unrestricted news trading create opportunities that The5ers simply doesn't offer, though you'll sacrifice 10-20% of profits for these features.
For most traders, The5ers wins on the fundamentals that matter most: you keep more of what you earn, and you're dealing with a firm that's proven itself over time. Unless you specifically need MT4/MT5 or news trading capabilities, the superior profit split and established reputation make The5ers the stronger choice.
Choose The5ers if:
→Scale up to $4M in funded trading capital with industry-leading spreads
→Up to 100% profit split with transparent one-time fees
→Unlimited time limit for evaluations with no consistency rules
→24/7 support and guidance with free educational resources
Choose Blue Guardian if:
→Instant funding accounts available - skip evaluation phases entirely
→Scale up to $4M in funding capacity
→Instant payouts and 24-hour payout guarantee available
→Multiple account types including 1-step, 2-step, and 3-step challenges
Disclaimer:This comparison is for informational purposes only. Prop firm rules change regularly — always verify current terms on each firm's official website before purchasing a challenge. This is not financial advice. Updated 2026-03-08.